‘You see nurses at the end of their shifts parking their cars and just crying’
Sparrow caregivers call for fairer pay, benefits amid pandemic
Sparrow Hospital workers call for fairer pay and better benefits at Wednesday’s “informational picket.” | Anna Gustafson
Carrying signs emblazoned with “patients over profits,” hundreds of nurses and other health care providers marched outside Sparrow Hospital Wednesday evening to call for fairer wages and benefits needed to retain and attract the workers that union representatives said the hospital has been “hemorrhaging” during the COVID-19 pandemic.
“Now is our time to stand up and speak out for what we deserve: fair pay, affordable health insurance and a safe environment in which to work,” said Katie Pontifex, a Sparrow Hospital nurse and the president of the Professional Employee Council of Sparrow Hospital (PECSH). The PECSH represents about 2,200 Sparrow workers and is a local subset of the Michigan Nurses Association.
The union-organized “informational picket” on Wednesday — meaning no participant took time off from work to attend — comes days after the contract for Sparrow’s nurses and other health care providers expired on Oct. 30.
The hospital and caregivers have until Friday to ratify a current contract offer, which union organizers said will likely not happen because it includes a 12% spike in health insurance costs for workers and a 4% wage increase that staff said does not reflect cost of living increases. The contract offer will make it increasingly difficult to retain and attract workers, union representatives said, noting that the hospital needs at least 90 more nurses to have a full staff.
If you are awake in 2021, you know this is a workers’ revolution right now. Every corner of the state is on fire.
– Rep. Sarah Anthony (D-Lansing)
“Staffing is a huge problem, and it’s a recruitment and retention issue,” said Julie Mason, a clinical laboratory scientist in Sparrow Hospital’s microbiology department. “We are short-staffed. You see nurses at the end of their shifts parking their cars and just crying. It’s just not OK.
“The short staffing hasn’t been a new problem, and it’s been exacerbated during COVID,” Mason continued. “Nurses are having to do more with less. Instead of taking care of their two or three patients, now it’s four, five, six, seven, eight, nine patients. It’s ridiculous. They can’t keep doing that.”
In addition to the stress of working while short-staffed during the pandemic and health care workers increasingly facing aggressive and violent patients and families, caregivers said they also lost benefits from their employer during COVID-19.
“Last year, during a pandemic, the health care professionals and nurses at Sparrow lost their longevity bonus, and this year they want to increase our health insurance costs?” Mason said. “Why would you increase health insurance for health care workers in a pandemic?”
A longevity bonus allows workers who have reached the top of their pay scale to receive bonuses in lieu of a wage increase; staff said such a bonus is crucial to attracting and retaining staff.
Sparrow said in a prepared statement that it is routinely meeting with union organizers to finalize a contract that will include competitive wages and benefits. The hospital noted that it faced a $31 million operating loss in 2020 and that it expects an operating loss in 2021, as well.
“Sparrow has the highest respect for all our caregivers, and we value them and the work they do every day to care for patients and families,” the hospital said in its statement. “Like health systems across the country, we continue navigating staffing challenges but remain committed to staffing ratios that are consistent with, or better than, peer hospitals and meet or exceed legislation mandating caregiver staffing ratios in other states.
“At the bargaining table, we have made several proposals to help improve our staffing levels and outside of negotiations we continue to post, approve and interview for positions,” Sparrow continued. “We also recruit and retain caregivers by participating in dozens of career fairs each year, recruit at schools around the state, offer referral, sign on and retention bonuses and reward caregivers who commit to additional shifts with cash bonuses up to $10,000, among many other initiatives.”
Those recruitment and retention efforts, however, are not working, nurses said.
“In the ER, we’ll work ourselves to the bone to get our work done [because of staffing shortages], but you can only sustain that for so long,” said LJ Knight, a nurse in Sparrow’s emergency room. “We’re losing experienced nurses. Either they’re retiring early or leaving the profession altogether.”
Pontifex said the hospital is “hemorrhaging staff in all of our areas.”
“It’s time we put a stop to it,” she said. “Sparrow’s [contract] proposal suggests a Band-Aid when we need a tourniquet.”
Lawmakers attending Wednesday’s informational picket said they want to see additional support for Sparrow’s caregivers.
“As of today, 2,200 of you are working without a contract after having worked through a global pandemic, putting your own health at risk daily, and your family’s health at risk, to serve your patients,” state Sen. Curtis Hertel (D-East Lansing) said. “You’ve been working extra hours with fewer staff and facing the politicization of the public health crisis; you’ve been physically, mentally and emotionally worn down. And for all of that we certainly say thanks, a thank you to all of our health care heroes.
“But that message, while appreciated, falls a little short when 2,200 of you are working without a contract,” Hertel continued. “ … Health care workers should be thanked, but they should be thanked by guaranteeing their safety and their patients’ safety is prioritized every single day.”
Like numerous speakers said throughout Wednesday’s event, Hertel emphasized there is not a nursing shortage but rather a dearth of well-paid positions for health care staff working in an ongoing pandemic.
We are short-staffed. You see nurses at the end of their shifts parking their cars and just crying. It’s just not OK.
– Julie Mason, a clinical laboratory scientist in Sparrow Hospital’s microbiology department
“You hear all about nurse shortages,” Hertel said. “We don’t have a shortage of skilled health professionals who are passionate about the work they do. Instead, we have workers who are not willing to continue to do more while getting less in return every single day.”
State Rep. Sarah Anthony (D-Lansing) and Ron Bieber, president of the Michigan AFL-CIO, noted that Sparrow’s informational picket comes at a time when workers across the state and country are calling for better conditions, including Kellogg workers in Battle Creek and McDonald’s staff in Detroit. The AFL-CIO is the state federation of labor that represents about one million active and retired members of 59 unions in Michigan,
“I am the proud product of two [United Auto Workers] parents, and they taught me that unions matter; solidarity matters,” Anthony said. “If you are awake in 2021, you know this is a workers’ revolution right now. Every corner of the state is on fire.”
Bieber, who read a statement of support for Sparrow staff from U.S. Rep. Elissa Slotkin (D-Holly) during Wednesday’s event, said, “it’s time for these greedy, rotten rich executives at Sparrow” to support workers.
“Workers have been abused for years and years and years and they’ve been tearing us down and tearing us down and tearing us down,” Bieber said. “And, sooner or later, they’re going to get sick of it. And they’re going to say, ‘Hell no, that’s enough; it’s time for us to take back our power and get back workers’ rights in this country.’”
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.